Dear jewelry friends, I have been married 18 years and although I paid very close attention to my e-ring (2.70 H color vvs clarity round brilliant set with flanked tapered baguettes), I quickly bought, sight unseen at the very last minute right before the wedding, my eternity wedding band. After that I just never thought about it other than to change from channel set to prong set. The reset didn’t help and I still dislike it. Now my jeweler tells me some cutlets were damaged during the reset and now my 2.5 tcw nice quality diamond band is really compromised. PS-I never really liked it anyway! So...... I fell instantly in LOVE with a vintage 100 year old Art Deco 3 tcw G color vvs eternity band that my new jeweler showed me. It’s got old mine cut rounds, baguettes and marquise. Just a stellar piece. Seeped in history and classy as heck! So far so good. But here’s my question. The e-ring is a size 5. The Art Deco wedding band is a size 5. But I’ve chewed up my finger taking the band on and off and I’ve only had it 24 hours!! My jeweler is super nice and told me to take it home “on approval”. Right now (after a glass or 2 of wine) it’s off my finger with no hope of getting back until tomorrow. I need your advice for on size for a wider wedding band such as this. Is this one simply too small? I really really want it to work. TIA all!